Disturbances at the polling station
6 September 2006 – At last March’s
local elections, members of polling committees in Bos en Lommer
dozens of times had to interfere physically to prevent ethnic minority
voters being assisted by their partner or children. The ombudsman
calls the proceedings ‘inappropriate’ and calls for
a discussion on changing the electoral law.
Members of polling committees frequently entered in discussions
with people to explain that it is not allowed to vote for other
people or to accompany them to the voting machine. “If that
did not help, the chairman or the vice-chairman would stand between
both persons, in order to prevent interference by putting up a physical
One chairman of a polling committee estimates that it was necessary
to interfere physically about twenty times. At other polling stations
as well, it was necessary to “interfere in all kinds of ways”,
says ombudsman Ulco van de Pol. The general impression is that the
situation at polling stations was ‘very turbulent’.
Voters wanted to be assisted because they were illiterate, had
language problems, or had difficulties with the new voting machines.
However, allowing them to be assisted brings along the risk that
their voting behaviour will be influenced.
Some voters did not really know what the elections were about.
For example, one person arrived with a note saying ‘I must
vote Wouter Bos’. Bos is the national party leader of the
social-democrat party and he was not a candidate at the local elections.
The voting committees improvised to deal with the problems, for
example by allowing persons to authorize someone else to vote on
their behalf, even though this is bending the law. The municipality
will provide instructions for the polling committees for the 22
November elections. It is hoped that this will ensure more uniformity
in how committees deal with problems.
Also, polling stations will be designed in such a way as to facilitate
surveillance of the voting machine.
The ombudsman calls for a national discussion about the electoral
law. The law does provide for assistance to people with physical
handicaps, but is very strict when it regards other kinds of barriers.
If high turnout is valued, changing the electoral law should at
least be considered, Van de Pol argues.
The ombudsman’s investigation was initiated at the request
of the Bos en Lommer district. Conservative council member Bas van
’t Wout will tomorrow ask for an investigation into voting
incidents in the other districts. The ombudsman expects that the
same problems will have occurred in all districts with large shares
of ethnic minorities, he does not think that a new investigation
is needed to find that out.
Also, the recommendations refer to the entire city, not just Bos
en Lommer. Furthermore, the ombudsman has finished the present investigation
fast to make sure that the findings can be used in the preparations
for the 22 November elections. A follow-up investigation might be
too late to be of any use.
Van ’t Wout: “As a council member and a resident of
this city, I would still very much like to know the extent of the
problem. After all, this is serious, it concerns the proper functioning
of democracy”. He also points out that six votes can sometimes
make the difference in district elections.
Should the extent of the problem be very large, then the procedures
regarding the election outcome may have to be changed, making it
easier to declare the outcome void, the council member says. Further,
he does not rule out that more opportunities must be provided to
practice voting on a voting machine, that is, if follow-up research
would show this to be the problem.
Van ’t Wout says that he is concerned about the public image
of the capital, because of the ‘clumsy’ way in which
the elections are organised. He is not only referring to the problems
in Bos en Lommer, but also to the fact that Amsterdam was one of
the last municipalities to introduce the voting machine, and that
there subsequently were power failures at a number of polling stations.
See also: Elections
Want to receive News from Amsterdam?